Department of Theology and islamic know ledge, Maha.C. , Islamic Azad University, mahallat, Iran.
Abstract: (31 Views)
cryptocurrencies, and accounting and disclosure practices of Islamic financial institutionsObjective: Cryptocurrencies, as digital assets that have neither a physical form nor a central issuer, have confronted the core concepts of Islamic transactional jurisprudence (fiqh al-mu’amalat), namely property value (maliyyah), possession (qabd), rescission (faskh) and liability (daman), with novel questions. Contemporary jurists and fatwa bodies hold divergent positions ranging from suspension and prohibition to conditional permissibility, and Iran’s regulatory framework is fragmented: cryptocurrencies are banned as a domestic means of payment, while licensed mining is permitted. Prior studies are mostly single-issue and Bitcoin-centred, and the questions of possession through private keys, the conflict between rescission and the irreversibility of blockchain transactions, and the relationship between individual and governmental jurisprudence have rarely been analysed systematically. The objective of this study is to develop a coherent framework of the declaratory (wad’i) and prescriptive (taklifi) rulings governing cryptocurrency transactions on the basis of the legal maxims and subject-matters of Imami jurisprudence. The study addresses one main question, namely what the jurisprudential rulings of cryptocurrency transactions are, and two sub-questions concerning (1) the legal maxims that govern these transactions and their scope, and (2) the way emerging subject-matters (the nature of the asset, possession, contractual characterization, options and liability) are measured against these maxims. The topic also matters for accounting and financial reporting, because the classification of cryptocurrencies affects their recognition, measurement and disclosure.
Method: The study is fundamental-theoretical in purpose and qualitative in nature, and adopts a descriptive-analytical method with an ijtihadi (inferential) approach. Since a ruling depends on a correct conception of its subject, the research proceeded in five steps: technical and economic identification of the subject; extraction of the major premise, i.e., the relevant legal maxims and their proofs; presentation of the emerging cases as the minor premise; evaluation of competing opinions; and consequence analysis within governmental jurisprudence. Data were collected through library and documentary research from primary jurisprudential sources, the opinions and fatwas of contemporary jurists, domestic and international scholarly articles, resolutions of Islamic fiqh academies and regulatory documents. The data were analysed using qualitative argumentative content analysis, and credibility was enhanced through source triangulation, systematic treatment of opposing views and the distinction between customary and jurist-derived subjects.
Results: First, reputable cryptocurrencies satisfy rational desire, lawful benefit, willingness to pay and exclusive appropriability; they therefore possess conventional property value, and the maxims of dominion (saltanah) and sanctity of property apply to them. A ban on their use as a means of payment does not negate their ownership. Second, the transparency of the distributed ledger negates uncertainty (gharar) in ordinary transactions, and price volatility is an economic risk rather than a legal gharar. Transactional usury (riba al-mu’amalah) does not apply, because cryptocurrencies are counted rather than measured or weighed and different coins constitute different genera; precaution is required only for unequal exchanges of stablecoins pegged to the same currency and, where monetary status (thamaniyyah) is established, same-session mutual possession should be observed as a precaution. Informed transactions constitute trade by mutual consent, whereas Ponzi schemes and rug pulls amount to unlawful consumption of property. Third, cryptocurrency is a digital conventional property whose types require differentiated rulings; through the theory of “conventional corporeality” (’ayniyyah i’tibariyyah), its transactions are characterized as sale (bay’), and mining is best explained as a public reward contract (ju’alah). Fourth, an on-chain transfer to an address controlled by the recipient’s private key, or the exclusive handover of the key, constitutes possession, at which moment the risk of loss passes to the buyer; custodial holdings create constructive possession under a deposit relationship. Fifth, these transactions are binding and subject to options. The conflict between rescission and irreversibility is resolved because rescission dissolves the contract from its own time, the impossibility of reversing the same transaction amounts to constructive loss, and cryptocurrencies are fungible; hence a reverse transaction operates as the return of the like, valued at the time of rescission. Sixth, the classical maxims of liability apply: hackers are strictly liable, project creators are liable for deception (ghurur), and centralized exchanges, as trustees, are liable for transgression or negligence. Seventh, the maxims of no-harm, negation of foreign domination (nafy al-sabil) and preservation of the social order justify regulation, not intrinsic prohibition.
Conclusion: Transactions in reputable cryptocurrencies are valid and permissible under Imami jurisprudence, which confirms the research hypothesis. The outcome of the conflict between individual dominion over property and the preservation of the social order is the theory of “conditional validation”, which combines the principle of legitimacy with mandatory registration, supervision and taxation, and directs regulators to supervise entry and exit gateways rather than to eliminate the protocol. The findings have practical implications for legislators, the Central Bank, the Securities and Exchange Organization, the judiciary and accounting standard setters: classifying unbacked coins as conventional property is consistent with the IFRS Interpretations Committee’s view that such cryptocurrencies are intangible assets or inventory, and the criterion of exclusive control over the private key aligns with the concept of control in the recognition of assets. Future research may address usury in decentralized lending protocols, khums and zakah on .
Zarei Kousha E, salimi A, Hosseini S A. Jurisprudential Rules and Subjects of Cryptocurrency Transactions: From Conventional Property Value to Conditional Validation. , audit knowledge. 2026; 26 (104) :1-31 URL: http://danesh.dmk.ir/article-1-3514-en.html